Category Archives: Interfaces

Explicit interface implementations (basic)

We have come across an interface example in my post Extension methods yesterday.

I am going to follow up on interfaces today.
Let’s have a look at an explicit and an implicit interface implementation:

public interface IInterfaceA {
    void MethodA();
class Implicit : IInterfaceA {
    public void MethodA() { }
class Explicit : IInterfaceA {
    void IInterfaceA.MethodA() { }
    //public void IInterfaceA.MethodA() { } // won't compile, cannot use the "public" modifier

The class Explicit does not allow a public modifier for MethodA(). This restricts the access.
Explicit interface implementations can only be accessed by using the interface directly. In the next example the compiler will complain about lExplicit.MethodA(). The instance lExplict cannot access the method, but the interface call b.MethodA() on the same object apparently is no problem. This way explicit interface implementation is used to hide members of a class.

void Test() {
    Implicit lImplicit = new Implicit();
    lImplicit.MethodA(); // business as usual
    IInterfaceA a = lImplicit;

    Explicit lExplicit = new Explicit();
    lExplicit.MethodA(); // compiler error
    IInterfaceA b = lExplicit;
    b.MethodA(); // works 🙂
} //

In theory we could simply write a class with an overridden modifier to have a similar behaviour. To tell you the truth right away: It won’t compile.

public class MyGeekClass : IInterfaceA {
    private void MethodA() { }  // compiler error: private modifier not allowed

Why does it not compile? First of all the private modifier does not exactly describe the public behavior via the interface instance.
Secondly using the private modifier would not solve naming issues. Interfaces support multiple inheritance, so the problem is a bit more tricky. Microsoft solved it in an appropriate way. Here is an example:

public interface ICat {
    void DoSomething();
public interface IDog {
    void DoSomething();
public class Animal : ICat, IDog {
    void ICat.DoSomething() { Console.WriteLine("Cat"); }
    void IDog.DoSomething() { Console.WriteLine("Dog"); }
static void Main(string[] args) {
    Animal lAnimal = new Animal();
    //lAnimal.DoSomething(); // compiler error
    ICat lCat = lAnimal;
    IDog lDog = lAnimal;
} //

example output:

Extension methods (advanced)

Overriding methods is old-fashioned, well-known and broadly used.

Since .NET 4.0 extension methods were added. You can now easily add new capabilities to existing types like classes, structs or interfaces.
Extension methods are defined as static methods but are called by using instance method syntax, their scope is their namespace. You have to explicitly import the namespace with a using directive unless you are in the right namespace already.

First of all you need to generate a static class, which is neither generic nor nested. Then use the this keyword on the first parameter of a static method.

namespace WeAreInTheSameNamespace {
    public static class ExtendingExistingTypes {

        public static double DoSomething(this double x, double y, int z) {
            return x * y * z;
        } //        

    } // class

    public static class ExtendingExistingTypesTest {
        public static void Test() {
            double x = 5.0;
            double r;
            r = x.DoSomething(4.0, 2); // static method called like an instance
            Console.WriteLine(r);   // = 40

            r = ExtendingExistingTypes.DoSomething(6.0, 7.0, 1);
            Console.WriteLine(r);   // = 42

        } //
    } ///
} // namespace

Did you realize the this keyword in public static double DoSomething(this double x, double y, int z) {}? It tells the compiler:

  • If someone uses the method DoSomething() as a standard static method, simply ignore the this keyword.
  • If the method is used like an instance method, then the first parameter is the instance itself. The second parameter becomes the first parameter.

Therefore we only have 2 parameters in the first method call [r = x.DoSomething(4.0, 2);] and 3 parameters in the second method call [r = ExtendingExistingTypes.DoSomething(6.0, 7.0, 1);].
The this keyword defines the type it is extending.

Have you seen such before? Sure, the most common extension methods are defined in interface IEnumerable. You probably just haven’t looked at them this way.

public static void Test2() {
    IEnumerable<double> lList = new double[] { 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0 };
    double d = lList.Average();  // extension method of an interface

} //

To avoid trouble you should be aware that extension methods have a lower priority than existing method signatures. Trying to override an existing method signature in an interface, struct or class is nonsense and will, due to its lower priority, never be called!

Extension methods are very useful when you cannot change the source code (eg. you don’t have the code of a library), but want to associate a new method with eg. the existing class without using override.

namespace NMyInterface {
    public interface IMyInterface {
        void MethodB();
    } // interface
} // namespace

// Define extension methods for IMyInterface. 
namespace NCoolExtensions {
    using NMyInterface;

    public static class MyExtension {
        public static void MethodA(this IMyInterface x, double d) { Console.WriteLine("Extension MethodA, double"); }
        public static void MethodA(this IMyInterface x, int i) { Console.WriteLine("Extension Method A, int"); }

        // Nonsense signature, the method will never be called because of its lower priority.
        public static void MethodB(this IMyInterface x) { Console.WriteLine("Extension nonsense"); }
    } // class
} // namespace

namespace NTestArea {
    using NCoolExtensions;
    using NMyInterface;

    class A : IMyInterface {
        public void MethodB() { Console.WriteLine("MethodB"); }
    } // class

    class B : IMyInterface {
        public void MethodA(int i) { Console.WriteLine("MethodA"); }
        public void MethodB() { Console.WriteLine("MethodB"); }
    } // class

    class C : IMyInterface {
        public void MethodA(object o) { Console.WriteLine("MethodA"); }
        public void MethodB() { Console.WriteLine("MethodB"); }
    } // class

    class D {
        public static void Test3() {
            Console.WriteLine("Class A");
            A a = new A();

            Console.WriteLine("Class B");
            B b = new B();

            Console.WriteLine("Class C");
            C c = new C();
            c.MethodA(new object());
        } //
    } // class
} // namespace

example output:
Class A
Extension Method A, int
Extension MethodA, double
Class B
Extension MethodA, double
Class C

Have a look at the output of Class C. MethodA(object o) hides all extension methods. Be cautious!